X Tutup
TVTropes Now available in the app store!
Open

Follow TV Tropes

Two-Fisted Tales

Go To

Two-Fisted Tales (trope)

Once upon a time, there was pulp. Pulp was a style of writing that emerged onto the scene in the 1920s, featuring a variety of stories printed on cheap paper (hence "pulp"). Back in the day, pulp content ranged from the Cosmic Horror Stories of H. P. Lovecraft to the noir pieces of Raymond Chandler and from the over-the-top action of Doc Savage to the Heroic Fantasy of Robert E. Howard's Conan the Barbarian and even the Raygun Gothic of Hugo Gernsback's Amazing Stories. At the same time, a similar type of adventure fiction was playing on theatre screens in the form of the Film Serial, thrill-a-minute short films that told an overarching story, and with each chapter typically ending in a Cliffhanger. The pulp era died down by the late '50s, when the leading distributor of pulp, the American News Company, went bankrupt, and television largely replaced the serial format.

There was a resurgence in The '60s and The '70s in three forms. The first was simple reprints of the older material: a lot of classic pulp writers were being rediscovered at the time, and being given their first printings in paperback form, with lush new covers by artists like Frank Frazetta or Boris Vallejo - often creating covers that ended up being far more iconic than the original meagre illustrations in the magazine printings.

The second was children's entertainment: creators who had grown up reading pulps and watching the serials wanted to recreate those same thrills for a new generation, and a lot of children's cartoon and comics (especially those aimed at boys) of the mid-20th Century reflect a very pulpy sensibility, albeit one cleaned up for younger viewers.

Finally, while the kids were thrilling to the adventures of Jonny Quest, their dads were reading the Darker and Edgier "men's adventure magazines", which straddled the line between pure pulp adventure and ostensibly-true Lurid Tales of Doom, often with confessional-style titles ("I Escaped from East Berlin!", for example), and always with a Rated M for Manly aesthetic. Technically, these were not pulp because they were printed on better-quality paper, but the two-fisted spirit was definitely there. These are today best-remembered as things to read at the barber shop while you waited for your turn, and were a regular fixture of the magazine rack up until the mid-1970s, when relaxed censorship laws in the U.S. gave rise to the porno magazines, and a lot of the men's adventure stuff went Hotter and Sexier in order to stay relevant. This move proved disastrous, as it not only failed to bring in the smut crowd, but it also alienated the readers who preferred the (relatively) clean adventure content they were used to. This magazine format, too, was thoroughly dead by 1980.

Nostalgia is cyclical, so it was only a matter of time before people started looking back fondly on pulp once again, and when they did, they usually locked onto the over-the-top stories of Proto-Superhero characters like The Shadow, Doc Savage, and The Phantom. Many point to Raiders of the Lost Ark and the sequel Indiana Jones movies, which took 1930s pulp adventures as an inspiration, as the keystone of the post-1980 pulp resurgence, but whatever kicked it off, pulp has recaptured the heart of many a geek.

Two-Fisted Tales refers to stories told in a style that reflects fondly on the old pulps. This usually means the story will be set in the '20s or '30s, and focus on square-jawed, clever men (and women) of action. Other elements thrown in for flavor include:

As stated above, Two-Fisted Tales don't often attempt to recapture the varied feel of all the old pulps; it's very rare you'll see someone trying to overlay the Doc Savage feel onto a Cthulhu story (not that it's impossible). Usually, it attempts to focus on the thrilling heroics, not that that's a bad thing.

While most works in the genre are not set during the interwar "pulp era" (though the occasional one, such as The Treasure of the Sierra Madre [1948], is), The Western could be considered an inherently pulpy genre, thanks to it frequently featuring heightened reality, an exotic historical setting (often nostalgically rendered), double-fisted machismo, a sensationalistic tone, plenty of action and/or adventure, print-the-legend storytelling, larger-than-life mythmaking, and fairly clear lines of morality. There were also a lot of pulp magazines devoted specifically to publishing western fiction, so there is, at the very least, plenty of overlap.

Related to Diesel Punk and Jungle Opera. Often the subject of a Genre Throwback. See also Ninja Pirate Zombie Robot, Twice-Told Tale which requires a specific tale. Also see Sword and Sorcery for a similarly campy style of adventure narrative that was popular around the same time.

If you're an author; see Write a Jungle Opera


Examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Anime & Manga 

    Comic Books 

    Fan Fiction 
  • The Many Secret Origins of Scootaloo: The version of Daring Do in the eighth chapter is this trope. It centers around the sale of a legendary diamond in a mafia-owned cabaret, complete with gunfights and a young street urchin who helps out the heroes.

    Films — Animation 

    Films — Live-Action 

Examples by creator:

Examples by work title:

    Literature 

Examples by creator:

  • The work of Edgar Rice Burroughs, providing some of the definitive examples of some of this trope's subgenres.
    • Tarzan, his most famous character, is one of the definitive pulp heroes, practically defining the Jungle Opera subgenre: Tarzan is a man raised by apes to become king of the jungle — basically what you'd get if Mowgli were an action hero. His stories are full of lost cities and grand adventure.
    • The Land That Time Forgot and its sequels tell a classic Lost World tale of dinosaurs, feuding tribes of cavemen, volcanic eruptions, and a square-jawed American hero (played by Doug McClure in the movie) who must sort it all out.
    • The Pellucidar series is basically a pulp adventure take on Journey to the Center of the Earth, with a subterranean Lost World full of good-looking primitive humans, diabolical monsters, plenty of dinosaurs, and a different square-jawed American hero (though one also played by Doug McClure in the movie) who must sort it all out.
    • The John Carter of Mars novels are classic Planetary Romance works, with a richly-drawn world of trackless desert, proud warrior race guys, Weird Science, daring escapes, heroic rescues, airship battles, sword fights, and a square-jawed American hero (whom, sadly, Doug McClure never got to play) who must sort it all out.
  • Publisher and editor Robert Deis (and a rotating crew of co-editors) has released a whole series of anthology books collecting stories originally published in men's adventure magazines. They include such attention-grabbing titles as:
    • Weasels Ripped My Flesh!: A grab bag of multiple subgenres.
    • Cuba: Sugar, Sex, and Slaughter: All stories that involve Castro and the Cuban Revolution.
    • Cryptozoology Anthology: Stories and articles about cryptids.
    • I Watched Them Eat Me Alive!: Animal attack stories.
    • Maneater: More animal attack stories, but specifically Threatening Shark stories.
    • Atomic Werewolves and Man-Eating Plants: When the men's adventure stuff overlapped with weird fiction, bringing us the occult, Hollywood Satanism, more cryptids, robots, and aliens, as well as a reprint of H. P. Lovecraft's Gothic Horror nightmare "The Rats in the Walls".
    • The Naked and the Deadly: A collection of stories by Lawrence Block, most of which skew towards Detective Fiction and the noirish.
    • Handful of Hell: All stories by prolific writer Robert F. Dorr, nearly all of which are war fiction.
    • He-Men, Bag-Men, and Nymphos: Stories by Walter Kaylin, ranging from the noirish to Nazisploitation to Spy Fiction, but all of them extremely over-the-top, violent, and horny.
  • Philip José Farmer's long writing career is marked by his great love of the pulps, and he devoted great energy to his many Two-Fisted Tales. Even his works which aren't in the genre are often informed by it. Doc Savage: His Apocalyptic Life provides a biography of the pulp era hero and links him to other period heroes.
  • Kim Newman's Dr. Shade... sometimes. Some of the stories featuring him are celebrations of the pulps and others (most especially "The Original Dr. Shade") are Deconstructions. Also by Newman but not featuring Dr. Shade: the Diogenes Club story "Clubland Heroes" (definitely a Deconstruction).
  • Manly Wade Wellman was a prolific writer of pulp fiction, who wrote for a wide range of weird fiction magazines, particularly Weird Tales. He's best remembered for the Silver John series of Fantasy Americana stories, though he also wrote ghost stories, prehistoric fiction, and one of the Captain Future novels.

Examples by work title:

  • "Adventure Story" by Neil Gaiman is narrated by the son of a WWII soldier who had this type of experience post-war.
  • Andrew Doran: Andrew Doran is a Doc Savage-esque Genius Bruiser and square-jawed hero, even if he's more obnoxious and prideful than the majority of pulp heroes. He's up against Nazis, evil cultists, and monsters. The books are done in a deliberate episodic pulpy style reminiscent of older serialized fiction.
  • Baccano!, a Prohibition-era story with gangsters, serial killers and immortal alchemists, told in Pulp Fiction-style Anachronic Order.
  • The Bagman, a former gangaster turned masked protector of the innocent in 1930s Chicago.
  • The Bernice Summerfield novel Down by Lawrence Miles features "Mr. Misnomer, the Man of Chrome", who Benny knows for a fact is a fictional character from 24th century "pulpzines". It also features a hollow world full of dinosaurs, a Nazi villain, a mad computer and all the usual stuff. Turns out to be a deconstruction.
  • Biggles had a few adventures that dabbled in this genre between the wars. It looked as though he were going to end up doing the same thing again after World War II, but instead he got a job offer from a comrade in arms who'd gone back to his prewar career as a police inspector, and spent the next decade or so being Biggles of the Yard instead.
  • Mark Stephen Rainey's Blue Devil Island featuring the Blue Devil Squadron facing off against an Eldritch Abomination in the South Pacific during World War II.
  • The Books of Cthulhu series takes a very pulp hero version of the Cthulhu Mythos, with protagonists that are unafraid to oppose the various cultists as well as forces threatening the world. Occasionally subverted where the protagonists Broke Your Arm Punching Out Cthulhu.
  • The Captain Riley series by Fernando Gamboa, featuring a Ragtag Bunch of Misfits on a Cool Boat fighting (who else?) Those Wacky Nazis.
  • Paul Malmont's pulp-homage novel The Chinatown Death Cloud Peril has the authors of Doc Savage and The Shadow looking into the murder of H. P. Lovecraft and uncovering a global conspiracy.
  • The Ciaphas Cain books follow this style, with the added twist that the narrator protagonist keeps insisting his acts of daring-do are misinterpretations or just what was necessary to survive.
  • In a more lighthearted variant, the Doc Wilde series. Doc even brings his kids along on his adventures.
  • The novel Gods of Manhattan, in the Pax Britannia series of Steampunk novels, features two-fisted adventurer Doc Thunder (Doc Savage, with elements of Hugo Danner and Superman), and killer vigilante Blood Spider (The Spider, with elements of The Shadow), amongst others.
  • Lagadin's Legacy features elements of the Indiana Jones-style adventure story, with elements of thriller, mystery, and satire.
  • Lost Horizon (1933) is an adventure novel in which the crew of a crashed airplane are stranded in the Himalayas. It is generally credited with popularizing the trope of The Shangri-La.
  • Zach Parsons specifically called his book My Tank is Fight! an example of "two-fisted pulp history", with a title taken from a punk rock song by The Darkest of the Hillside Thickets. It describes the development and hypothetical use of various super-strange World War II weapons that never quite made it past the prototype stage (if they made it that far at all).
  • The Takers is an Indiana Jones-style homage novel by Jerry Ahern, about an action-adventure novelist and his Love Interest — an Intrepid Reporter who investigates wacky UFO and occult stories — who team up to investigate the murder of a CIA agent, and the log of a 19th Century expedition searching for Atlantis. It manages to work in Pirates, Ancient Astronauts, Mysterious Antarctica, Flying Saucers, Those Wacky Nazis, a Diabolical Mastermind and his Psycho Knife Nut daughter, and a nuclear submarine!
  • In the Wax and Wayne series, interludes in the book parts have snippets of the in-universe "broadsheets" featuring headlines, advertisements, and bits of pulp fiction stories. The most recurring being the (heavily embellished) real life adventures of "Allomancer Jak".

    Live-Action TV 

    Podcasts 

    Tabletop Games 
  • Achtung! Cthulhu is taking all the World War II and post-war pulps about punching Those Wacky Nazis and disrupting their wicked schemes and gives them a ride through the Cthulhu Mythos country.
  • Crimefighters is a pulp-themed, role-playing tabletop game from 1981. It emulates the quests of popular Crime and Detective pulp characters (such as Doc Savage, the Shadow, and Agent X-9) against criminal masterminds. The game presents three character classes: the Defender, an in-universe Lawful Good that fights crime and gains experience by capturing, not killing, offenders; the Avenger, an in-universe Chaotic Good with a penchant for vigilantism and therefore gains experience points by killing criminals; and the Pragmatist, in-universe Neutral Good, that usually abides by the law but is willing to break it in order to bring villains to justice.
  • Crimson Skies, later adapted into a series of PC and Xbox games, focuses heavily on the Zeppelins and Sky Pirates aspect of pulp.
  • d20 Modern: The Pulp Heroes setting in d20 Past, full of dashing aviators and mad Nazi science.
  • Dungeons & Dragons: While the base game certainly can fit this trope (typically with a strong Heroic Fantasy flavour), a few campaign settings in particular stand out:
  • Fists & .45s was created by dredging out few cardboard boxes of old pulps and then trying to work them out into a game. Unlike most cases, this game is heavy on the actual content of the pulps, rather than their aesthetics alone, only adding to the craziness.
  • In Fortune and Glory, players take on the roles of pulp archetypes — an Ace Pilot, an Intrepid Reporter, a Mad Scientist, a Great White Hunter — in a globe-trotting adventure to recover mystical artifacts before a Nebulous Evil Organization (In addition to Those Wacky Nazis, we have The Mafia and a Religion of Evil) gets them first.
  • Gear Krieg is very much this at heart, with heavy Diesel Punk trappings.
  • Genius: The Transgression gives detailed instructions on how to create a pulp tale in the sourcebook.
  • GURPS is generic enough to handle the setting, as seen in GURPS Cliffhangers and GURPS Thaumatology: Age of Gold.
  • Hollow Earth Expedition is made of this, to the point its mechanics were build from ground-up toward larger than life heroes doing crazy stunts and simply powering through lesser or trivial obstacles. Large section of the core rulebook is dedicated to explaining in detail how to recapture the feel of a Film Serial in your own scenario, too.
  • Many adventures had by the Sons of Ether in Mage: The Ascension, whose Tradition is chock-full of people with names like "Doc Eon" and "the Crimson Claw". Taking an appropriately two-fisted nickname seems to be standard even if you don't use it often.
  • Pulp Cthulhu does this to the parent game Call of Cthulhu, turning the fraidy investigators to pulp heroes by tweaking the game rules, and adding Weird Science in mix with the traditional Lovecraftian setting, resulting a setting where insane adventurers are bad news... for the adversaries!
  • Rocket Age is intended to have a pulpy, heroic play-style, in a Raygun Gothic Space Opera setting. It even has a story point system to let you manipulate the plot and pull off almost impossible stunts and bluffs.
  • If Savage Worlds can be said to have a "default setting", it's this. One of the first supplements was a Pulp Toolkit, another supplement/source book is named Thrilling Tales, and the whole system's emphasis on "Fast Furious Fun!" leads to a very pulpy game experience.

    Video Games 

    Webcomics 
  • Girl Genius is based strongly off pulpy stories of juvenile adventurers like Tom Swift and Jonny Quest. In-universe, the Heterodyne stories, (often exaggerated) tales about the adventures of heroes Bill and Barry Heterodyne, are enormously popular.
  • The currently comatose "Modern Pulp" webcomic site, especially Sprecken, about a 1930s crimefighter (who used to go by "Mr. Midnight") relocated to the 2020s.
  • Semi-Auto Semla seeks to emulate the genre and the tone, complete with the gratuitous numbers of damsels in distress and heavy-duty action.

    Web Originals 
  • The semiprozine Cirsova Magazine was specifically conceived as a place for good ol' pulp-style sci-fi and fantasy stories.
  • The Mirror of Amun-Ra is an affectionate Genre Throwback to the Indiana Jones films, The Mummy Trilogy, and other such Adventurer Archaeologist stories.
  • Pulpcovers.com is a blog that posts the cover art — and sometimes interior illustrations — from pulp magazines and old paperbacks. Sometimes they include a link to a pdf of the original magazine, too.
  • Reddit: r/Pulp is a subreddit devoted to the creation of modern pulp fiction, juicy taglines and lurid covers included.
  • Wormwood: A Serialized Mystery is a pulpy horror story centering around the mysterious northern Californian town of Wormwood.
  • The YouTube channel Mutant Museum features dramatic readings of - among other things - stories from old pulp magazines. These are largely divided into three main series: True Dread! (horror stories), True Wonder! (fantasy and science fiction), and True Excitement! (general adventure, mystery, or romance content).

    Western Animation 

Alternative Title(s): Two Fisted Tale

Top
X Tutup