"General Hague... is doing Deep Space Nine. It seems he was double-booked by his agent and there was nothing to be done, so you'll have to do with me, sir."
In the entertainment world, actors, directors, and other creatives often have to drop out of projects when their schedules don’t allow them to work on it.
For TV shows, sometimes a character’s role would be reduced for an episode or more due to appearing in a movie or an episode of another show. This could also lead the actor to leave the show for good.
Sub-trope of Real Life Writes the Plot. Compare with Creative Differences, another reason for someone to drop out.
Examples:
open/close all folders
Films — Live-Action
- Back to the Future 1:
- When the movie was being filmed, Michael J. Fox was considered for the role of Marty McFly, but he was already busy with Family Ties. Eric Stoltz was cast as Marty instead. When behind-the-scenes conflicts led to Stoltz being fired, Fox was called back for the role. The solution was to have him work on Family Ties during the day and Back to the Future during the night.
- Claudia Wells was originally cast as Jennifer opposite Stoltz as Marty, but she had to drop out due to the fact that a pilot she had starred in got picked up, resulting in her being committed to a TV series called Off the Rack. Shortly after Stoltz was fired, Wells' replacement Melora Hardin was let go as well since executives didn't like the fact that she was noticeably taller than Fox. By this point, Off the Rack had been cancelled, allowing Wells to play Jennifer after all.
- Big Daddy: Harold Ramis was considered for Arthur Brooks but declined due to directing Analyze This.
- Black Sheep (1996): Chris Farley was approached to star as Chip Douglas in The Cable Guy. However, he and David Spade were contractually-obligated on with Black Sheep, Jim Carrey ended up playing Chip, instead.
- The Blue Lagoon: Valerie Bertinelli was considered for the female lead but was unable to do the role due to her commitment to One Day at a Time. Her role on the show also prevented her from appearing on The Big Chill and Footloose.
- Carry On... Series:
- Following Carry On, Sergeant, Dora Bryan was hoped to become a regular in the series and star once more in Carry On Nurse. However, Bryan was unavailable, and the role of Nurse Dawson was given to Joan Sims, who went on to appear in more Carry Ons than any other actress.
- Carry On Jack was the first Carry On to not star Kenneth Connor, who had commitments in the West End in A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum and couldn't make the shooting dates.
- Bernard Cribbins turned down the role of Hengist Pod in Carry On Cleo to do a play instead. His role was then given to Kenneth Connor.
- Carry On Screaming!:
- Sergeant Bung was written for Sid James, who was already doing Babes in the Wood on stage, so the role went to Harry H. Corbett.
- Deborah Kerr was the first choice for Valeria. Kerr turned down the role in favor of a stage version of Flowers for Algernon, so it then went to Fenella Fielding.
- Sid James was intended to play Sergeant Nocker in Follow That Camel, if it hadn't been for his commitments for the ITV Britcom George and the Dragon. The role was instead given to Phil Silvers as Stunt Casting.
- Carry On Up the Khyber:
- Jim Dale had to turn down the role of Captain Keene because of stage commitments, so the role went to Roy Castle.
- Both Frankie Howerd and Tommy Cooper were offered the role of the Fakir. Just like Dale, they were busy on the stage, so the role was given to Cardew Robinson.
- In Carry On Again Doctor, Patricia Franklin had been asked to appear briefly as a night nurse, which she had to turn down as she was busy on the stage. Her small part then went to Jenny Counsell.
- For Carry On Up the Jungle, Kenneth Williams was too busy starring in The Kenneth Williams Show to play Professor Tinkle, so the role went to Frankie Howerd.
- Jacki Piper was hoped to be in Carry On Henry, only for her to be too busy working in the West End.
- Barbara Windsor turned down a role in Carry On at Your Convenience so she could instead appear in The Boy Friend.
- Carry On Matron:
- Bill Maynard was only cast as Freddy as the first choice, Peter Butterworth, already had other commitments.
- During the shooting of Up the Jungle, Frankie Howerd had wanted to return for whatever film they'd make in October 1971. Despite this, he ended up unavailable as he was making Up the Chastity Belt at the same time.
- After impressing the cast and crew on the set of Matron, Madeline Smith was asked back for Carry On Abroad. As Smith was busy at the time, the role of Lily went to Sally Geeson, who was suggested by Sid James, her Bless This House co-star.
- Carry On Girls:
- Kenneth Williams turned down the roles of Mayor Bumble and Mr. Gaybody as he was appearing onstage in My Fat Friend and didn't want to waste any of his energy. His planned roles went to Kenneth Connor and Jimmy Logan.
- Bill Maynard had been cast as the Police Inspector before dropping out in favor of a better-paying TV job, leading to the casting of David Lodge.
- Hattie Jacques was wanted to appear in a cameo role as the maternity hospital Matron. As she was too busy starring in Sykes, Brenda Cowling filled her role.
- Carry On Behind:
- The parts of Fred Ramsden and Norma Baxter were written for Sid James and Barbara Windsor. Both were unavailable; the former in Australia doing a run of The Mating Game and the latter was touring New Zealand doing her variety show Carry On Barbara!. To fill their parts, Jack Douglas suggested Windsor Davies for Fred, while Adrienne Posta was brought on as Norma.
- Chris Gannon had been cast as the barman before getting a job that could pay more. To avoid any issues, Gannon's agent got Kenneth Waller to fill the part.
- Carry On England:
- The Brigadier had been written for Kenneth Williams before going to Peter Jones as the former was busy onstage in a production of Signed and Sealed.
- Barbara Windsor turned down Diane Langton's role, Private Easy, as she was busy on TV in The Mike Reid Show.
- Sid James was not considered for the film because he was still touring with the stage play The Mating Season, although in a cruel irony, the day that the pre-production meeting was scheduled was the day that he died of a heart attack on stage.
- Hattie Jacques was the first choice to play Mrs. Valentine in Carry On Emmannuelle. When it was discovered that Jacques was too busy onstage in A Hatful of Sykes, the role went to Beryl Reid.
- Bernard Bresslaw and Barbara Windsor were so unimpressed with the script for Carry On Columbus that they chose to do the end-of-pier stage show Wot a Carry On in Blackpool instead. The roles of the King and Queen of Spain instead went to Leslie Phillips and June Whitfield.
- Doctor... Series:
- For Doctor in Love, producer Betty Box wanted to use Kenneth More as Grimsdyke once again, but he was busy with another film. As a result, Grimsdyke was replaced by Leslie Phillips as Dr. Burke.
- Phillips was then due to return as Dr. Burke for the next film, Doctor in Distress (1963), but had to turn it down, owing to an irreversible conflict. This led to the series' original leading man, Dirk Bogarde, playing Dr. Sparrow one final time.
- Ghost in the Shell: Margot Robbie was in early talks to play the Major, but she eventually chose to play Harley Quinn for Suicide Squad (2016) instead.
- Originally, Mike Nichols wanted Burt Ward for the lead in The Graduate but Ward wouldn't be granted a leave from Batman (1966) and so Nichols had to go with his second choice, Dustin Hoffman, the role of Benjamin becoming Hoffman's Star-Making Role. For the rest of his life, Nichols was apologetic to Ward, knowing that he had missed out unfairly on the role.
- Jaws 3-D: Deliberately invoked by Roy Scheider, who signed up for Blue Thunder to ensure he would be unavailable for Jaws 3-D.
- The Lord of the Rings Film Trilogy: Russell Crowe was offered to play the role of Aragorn, but he turned it down to film A Beautiful Mind.
- Passport to Pimlico: Because Jack Warner was busy with another film, the role of Arthur Pemberton ended up being played by Stanley Holloway.
- The Producers (1967): Dustin Hoffman was originally cast in the role of Franz Liebkind but dropped out after landing the role in The Graduate. Mel Brooks joked that he only allowed Hoffman to audition for Graduate because his wife was the female lead, so he couldn't very well claim The Producers was the better film. He was also convinced that Hoffman would not be cast, as the role had called for a blonde actor.
- Pure Country: Robert Duvall was considered for Ernest Tucker, but he was unable to due to doing projects like Newsies and The Plague.
- Raiders of the Lost Ark:
- In 1975, George Lucas collaborated with Philip Kaufman on an early version of Raiders, with Kaufman notably being the one who came up with the idea of using The Ark of the Covenant as the film's MacGuffin. The plan was that Kaufman would direct it, but he had to turn it down due to his commitment to The Outlaw Josey Wales. Lucas therefore put the project on hold until after Star Wars, at which point he gave it to Steven Spielberg instead. For his contributions to the story, Kaufman is given a co-writer credit.
- Spielberg wanted Tom Selleck as Indiana Jones, but he was busy gearing up for his Star-Making Role on Magnum, P.I. and couldn't join in. The What Could Have Been nature of the situation was later parodied on the show when Magnum spent an episode in a fedora and leather jacket reminiscent of Indy's.
- Shock Treatment:
- Barry Bostwick was busy with another film, so Cliff DeYoung (the first choice for Brad in The Rocky Horror Picture Show) stepped up to fill the role.
- During production, Jonathan Adams was working in the West End in a production of Tomfoolery. As a result, Dr. Scott was dropped from the script and replaced by Bert Schnick, played by Barry Humphries.
- The Story of Robin Hood and His Merrie Men: Robert Newton was cast as Friar Tuck. However, the role had to go to James Hayter after Newton was also cast in Androcles and the Lion.
- X-Men Film Series:
- X-Men 1: Dougray Scott was originally cast as Wolverine but had to drop out before filming began due to Mission: Impossible II encountering Troubled Production and going over-schedule.
- X-Men: Apocalypse: Taron Egerton was offered the role of Cyclops, but turned it down to work on Eddie the Eagle.
Live-Action TV
- 'Allo 'Allo!: The first choice for Officer Crabtree was Edward Duke, who had also gotten an offer to take his one-man show, Jeeves Takes Charge, abroad. Arthur Bostrom was then cast, thanks to previously working for David Croft in the Hi-de-Hi! episode, "The Society Entertainer".
- American Ninja Warrior: Jessie Graff withdrew from the 2019 season when Wonder Woman 1984, a movie she did stuntwork for, went into reshoots, causing a schedule conflict. She actually had a choice between the two, but being a noted superhero fan (as evidenced by the outfits she wears on ANW) led her to choose Wonder Woman.
- Are You Being Served?:
- Larry Martyn was asked to once more play Mr. Mash in Series 4, but he had commitments on Spring and Autumn. As a result, Arthur English replaced him as Mr. Harman.
- That same year, Moira Foot was asked back to play Miss Thorpe, Mr. Rumbold's secretary, which she couldn't do as she had already been booked for The Benny Hill Show.
- When Series 8 was announced, Trevor Bannister had already accepted a role in a run of the stage play Middle-Age Spread. This, coupled with the belief that the series was beginning to go downhill, led to Mr. Lucas being replaced by Mr. Spooner. Mike Berry says this change happened so soon to shooting that he was given early scripts with "Lucas" crossed out and "Spooner" written over it in pencil.
- Babylon 5: Robert Foxworth was supposed to reprise his role as General Hague in the third season episode "Severed Dreams". However, his agent mistakenly booked him onto the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine two-parter "Homefront" and "Paradise Lost", scheduling for filming at the same time. Nobody noticed the double-booking until it was too late, resulting in Hague being Killed Offscreen and providing this trope with its pagequote.
- Birds of a Feather (1989):
- Alun Lewis was asked back for Series 7, only he was unavailable due to his commitment to Emmerdale. Following this, Darryl was recast with Douglas McFerran.
- Matt Willis was supposed to return in Series 11, if not for the commitments to his band McBusted. Because of this, Samuel James became the fourth actor to play Garth.
- The Brittas Empire: Commitments to Emmerdale meant that Andrée Bernard was unable to play her role as Angie beyond Series 1, with Julie Porter written as a Suspiciously Similar Substitute from Series 2 onwards.
- Cadfael: Ian Holm was originally cast to play Brother Cadfael, but delays in pre-production led to him moving on to other projects. Derek Jacobi was cast as a replacement.
- Chiquititas (2013): Gésio Amadeu, who played Chefe Chico in the 1997 version, was asked to play the character again in this version. However, at the time he was filming the telenovela Flor do Caribe for Globo, which made him unable to return, and thus he reccomended his friend João Acaiabe for the role.
- Dad's Army:
- Jon Pertwee turned down the role of Captain Mainwaring as he was in the middle of a theatrical tour, leaving it open for Arthur Lowe.
- Rosemary Faith (who had played Ivy Samways in "Mum's Army") was supposed to return to the role in "My British Buddy", but Faith was appearing in a production of Gypsy, so Ian Lavender's then-wife, Suzanne Kerchiss, was brought in as The Other Darrin.
- Game of Thrones: Daenerys Targaryen was originally going to be played by Tamzin Merchant, but was replaced by Emilia Clarke due to scheduling issues.
- The Good Life: If not for his commitments at the Royal Court, Jerry would've been played by Peter Bowles instead of Paul Eddington.
- Goodnight Sweetheart: Dervla Kirwan chose not to return for Series 4 onwards to focus on her other series, Ballykissangel. The choice to recast Phoebe with Elizabeth Carling was also Kirwan's choice.
- Hi-de-Hi!:
- John Quayle was the first choice for Jeffrey Fairbrother. Due to commitments with the National Theatre, the role instead went to Simon Cadell.
- Susan Beagley didn't come back for Series 6 as she was busy in the West End. Because fellow Yellowcoat Rikki Howard was also unavailable (albeit due to pregnancy), it was decided to cast Linda Regan, Laura Jackson, and Julie-Christian Young as a trio of new Yellowcoats.
- Last of the Summer Wine: When a new "third man" was needed for Series 9 following Brian Wilde leaving the series, Fulton Mackay was suggested before it was discovered that he was too busy with Fraggle Rock. In the end, Michael Aldridge was brought in as Seymour Utterthwaite.
- The Muppet Show: Parodied extensively in season 2, episode 21: Bob Hope was supposed to be the Special Guest for the episode, but could only find the time to record one full segment amidst his schedule of charity fundraisers. The writers made fun of this by having him repeatedly popping into the Muppet's theatre for brief visits between segments before immediately popping out to perform at various charity shows, then finally sticking around long enough to sing in "Don't Fence Me in
" note with a horse Muppet as the episode's final segment.
- Only Fools and Horses: The role of Danny Driscoll in "Little Problems" had been written for Anthony Hopkins, who was a big fan and sadly busy with The Silence of the Lambs. As a result, the role went to Roy Marsden.
- Remington Steele being unexpectedly picked up for a fifth season note derailed both stars' planned big-screen roles: Pierce Brosnan was offered the role of James Bond in The Living Daylights, while Stephanie Zimbalist was the preferred choice to play Ann Lewis in RoboCop (1987). Both had to drop out of their respective projects when NBC finally greenlit a new season of Steele. Brosnan would have to wait until 1995 to don the tuxedo in GoldenEye.
- Star Trek: In the final season of Star Trek: Discovery, Bridge Bunnies Owosekun and Detmer, both of whom had been on the show since the first season (and, in Detmer's case, since the first episode) are Put on a Bus due to actresses Oyin Oladejo and Emily Coutts having commitments to other shows. When the writers learned that DSC had been cancelled, a hastily-filmed Distant Epilogue managed to bring the characters back.
- Star Wars: Jon Favreau's choice for Din Djarin, Pedro Pascal, experienced this with principal photography for The Mandalorian Chapters 1-7, and apparently the complete filming of The Book of Boba Fett and The Mandalorian Season 3. Due to Pascal's involvement in such unrelated productions as Wonder Woman 1984, King Lear, The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent, and The Last of Us (2023), the majority of Din Djarin's appearances consist of Pascal dubbing over a separate performer wearing the full-body armor.
- Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles: Garret Dillahunt was always the first choice to play Cromartie, but was unavailable to film the pilot. This led to the subplot over the first few episodes of Cromartie, played in the pilot by Owain Yeoman, getting blown up and having to repair himself and create a new flesh covering.
- Till Death Us Do Part: Gretchen Franklin was Else in the series' Pilot, but couldn't do the first series as it clashed with a stage role she had. The casting of Dandy Nichols to replace her was Franklin's idea.
- Torchwood: Children of Earth: Freema Agyeman was supposed to reprise her role as Martha Jones. However, her commitment to Law & Order: UK meant that she was unable to appear at all. Initially, it was hoped that she would at least have some availability for a cameo, but even that became impossible. Instead, Lois was written in as a Suspiciously Similar Substitute, and Martha is explained as being off on her honeymoon and thus absent. Noel Clarke was also meant to reprise his role as Mickey Smith, but he was too busy doing film shoots.
- Upstairs, Downstairs: Series co-creator Eileen Atkins had been set to under-house parlourmaid Mary Buck until she pulled out dangerously close to recording to do the stage show Vivat! Vivat Regina!. The role was given to Pauline Collins, renamed "Sarah Moffat", and the rest is history.
- Young Sheldon: Billy Gardell played the Coopers' neighbor Herschel Sparks, but left the show due to his lead role on BOB ❤️ ABISHOLA, so his character was written out.
Radio
- The Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy: Susan Sheridan was the original voice of Trillian. She was unable to reprise the role in the second series owing to clashing theatrical and film commitments; rather than recast with a new actress, Douglas Adams and producer John Lloyd chose to write Trillian out completely. While she returned to reprise the role in the third series, one-off specials, and audiobooks, Susan is almost completely eclipsed as Trillian by the far more visible Sandra Dickinson in the TV series, and by Zooey Deschanel in the film adaptation.
- The Navy Lark:
- Dennis Price was unable to return for the second series as he was in New York doing the play Heartbreak House. As a result, Lieutenant Price was also shipped off to America in "New at the Helm", with Stephen Murray brought in as HMS Troutbridge's new Number One, Lieutenant Murray.
- When the series was Retooled into The TV Lark, Heather Chasen was unable to return as she was stuck with the long-running play A Severed Head. As Chasen played every female character, Janet Brown was drafted in to play a whole bunch of Suspiciously Similar Substitutes until Chasen returned for the sixth series.
- The increasingly popular Ronnie Barker left the series after Series 9 to appear in Frost on Sunday instead.
Theatre
- Girl Crazy (1930) was originally written with Bert Lahr's name attached to the leading role. However, Lahr signed up with a rival producer for the aviation-themed musical Flying High, which became a hit despite a troubled tryout, forcing the producers to cast Willie Howard instead.
Video Games
- Postal 4: No Regerts was initially set to have Rick Hunter reprise his role as the Postal Dude from Postal 2, but this fell through thanks to scheduling conflicts with Hunter's radio career. Thus the role instead went to Jon St. John. At least until the game's full release, where Rick Hunter managed to find time to reprise his role after all, allowing his voice (and several others) to be chosen as an option for the Postal Dude.
Western Animation
- KaBlam!: Julia McIlvaine, the voice of June, was unable to reprise her role for the Nicktoon World News shorts due to her already working on the CBS sitcom Danny. As a result, a different actress voiced June in the shorts, while Noah Segan continued his role as Henry.
